30 years of Fatalone Primitivo Riserva: A Report

Photo credit: John Carey Photography

The History of Fatalone

The Fatalone name originated with Filippo Petrera (2nd generation), Nicola‚Äôs son, who was, in his time, nicknamed Il Fatalone. It quickly caught on becoming the family nickname. Fatalone translates literally into ‘Lady Killer’ or ‘one who can boast to be an irresistible seducer of women’, much like the legendary Don Juan. Filippo Petrera lived until the age of 98, metaphorically speaking between Bacchus and Venus, having breakfast every morning till his last day with half a litre of Primitivo and half a litre of fresh milk.

In 1987, Fatalone became the first winery to produce and bottle the Gioia del Colle D.O.C. Primitivo as a single varietal wine. In 2000, in the spirit of promoting and the land and its local product, they founded the Consortium for the Protection of the Wines of D.O.C Gioia del Colle.

The estate has always practiced organic farming and since 2000 has been Certified Organic by the Institute for Ecology and Ethics Certification (I.C.E.A). In 2003, a new state-of-the-art cellar, carved in the rocks next to the ancient Masseria, was built combining ancient tradition with modern techniques and technology. The cellar is solar-powered, part of the Fatalone philosophy to work in an entirely sustainable fashion.

Place and grape

The area in question is called Gioia del Colle. The Fatalone vineyards are located between two seas: the Adriatic (45 km to the east) and the Ionian (45km to the south). The terrain comprises typical Murgian hilly karstic soil: a mix of clay and limestone, rocky and rich in minerals. To be exact it is composed of thin layers of red earth mixed with limestone and silica on huge monolithic blocks rich in marine fossils. These limestone soils confer freshness by preserving the acidity in the grapes, and since elegance in the wines is the main goal, help the Primitivo to realise its maximum potential.

Primitivo grapes (Photo credit: Fatalone)

Primitivo, a thin-skinned grape, is unique in having a second budding or veraison that occurs at the same time as the main crop (racemi). Alongside very few other grape varieties, if Primitivo tips are pruned in spring the secondary shoots, known as ‘femminelle’, will develop an abundance of small rounded clusters. These ‘racemes’ ripen approximately 20-30 days after the main grapes are harvested. This means that in Primitivo vineyards it is possible to have two separate harvests: the first in August to mid-September and the second¬†from the end of September to early October.

Although there has been debate about the variety’s geographical origins, there is little question that Primitivo’s modern-day home is in southern Italy, particularly Puglia. It probably arrived there from the coastal vineyards of Croatia, just across the Adriatic Sea, where it is still grown today under various tongue-twisting names including Tribidrag and Crljenak Kasteljanski.


The farming at Fatalone is organic and everything is done in the vineyard to ensure healthy grapes. After a manual harvest in small cases the grapes are destemmed into stainless tanks and undergo spontaneous fermentation, with pump overs to release carbonic gas. After several rackings the wine is transferred into Slavonian oak barrels (750 litres). No sulphur is added during the winemaking itself.

Music therapy is played to the barrels to assist the process of micro-oxygenation. This involves the diffusion of soft new age and classical music enriched with natural sounds (wind, rain, leaves movement, water flowing and chirping of birds), based on the idea that those soft vibrations improve the activity of the microflora present in the wine and support its breathing when in casks. After this careful maturation the wines are bottled without filtration and a very small addition of sulphites. All the wines are labelled 15% by volume (between 14.8% and 15.8%).

Music therapy is played to the barrels to assist the process…soft new age and classical music enriched with natural sounds, based on the idea that those soft vibrations improve the activity of the microflora present in the wine and support its breathing when in casks.

The classic Fatalone Primitivo in its youth is ruby red with slight burgundy hues. The aromas speak of very ripe fruits and slightly toasted wood and spices with some balsamic notes. Full bodied, rich in minerality and freshness, balanced smooth taste of black sour cherry and plum tending to velvety with ripe fruity notes of blackberry and mulberry, and spices like clove and cacao. The flavour that really distinguishes the authentic Primitivo from Gioia del Colle is the toasted almond aftertaste.

30 years of Fatalone ‚Äď the wines

The tasting, hosted by Pasquale Petrera, featured a vertical of vintages from 2012 back to 1988 with two pre-Fatalone wines from 1981 and 1977.

  • The 2012 presented rich liquorice and clove aromatics over prune, but retained an almost cool, minty finish with back notes of rose petals and dried flowers.
  • 2011 was a beautifully modulated wine, toned down concentration, pure, fragrant and elegant.
  • The chocolatey 2009 had a touch of botrytis, but the fine acidity kept the wine honest and long in the mouth.
  • 2007 proved to be an exceptional and one of the stars of the show. Its youthfulness was apparent, rich, dried fruit aromas and flavours with a distinctive savoury notes.
  • 2006 was a hot vintage and the Primitivo was holding a touch of residual sugar. The nose was sweet, but not confected, the finish had a bitter amaro/vermouth aspect.
  • 2005 was evidently a difficult vintage; having rained in August, the ripening was uneven. The resulting wine was powerful but missing some of the elegance and precision of the more eloquent vintages.
  • 2004 revealed some lovely maturity ‚Äď aromas of roast coffee, caramelized orange and secondary notes of earth, mushroom and truffle.
  • 2003 was very warm ‚Äď lots of baking spice and raw fruit. Less charming than some.
  • 2001 displayed an array of exotic spices ‚Äď cinnamon, clove and star anise seasoning the dried fruit flavours.
  • 2000 was terrific and arguably the wine of the line-up. Characterised by an initial bouquet of dried black olives, cured meat, it underpinned its rich chocolate-coated fruit with beautiful acidity. Really harmonious wine and still plenty to offer for the future.
  • Whereas the 1995 and 1991 were not showing so well, the 1988 was a revelation. Enticing bouquet of roasted pan juices, caramelized fruits and vegetables, dusted with herbs and a wonderful long finish with the acidity lingering on the tongue. A great wine.
  • The Ancestor‚Äôs Primitivo from 1981 was extremely turbid and viscous with a sweet rancio/muscat quality.
  • 1977, conversely, a naturally-made wine, was thrillingly fresh and limpid. Zesty red fruits, like a liqueur made out of baby red plums, and flecks of almond in the background.

Susan Hulme MW commented on the elegance of the wines: ‘I think the wines are not typical of what we have come to expect of Primitivo in the sense that they are more structural and restrained. They are not fruit and oak bombs.

‘The acidity and minerality and savoury almost salty qualities gives these wines the potential to age and this seems to be a reflection of some of the qualities of the soil and particular terroir.¬† I particularly liked the 1988, for example, which had great tenacity and liveliness as well as a gossamer fine texture. The 1977 was also so full of life.’

Darren Smith was also surprised: ‘I’ve only ever tried a handful of Primitivos and they’ve tended to be the fruit-bomb entry-level kind.

‘Apart from the alcohol level these were on the whole quite elegant wines, beautifully perfumed with a fine, silky texture. I’d certainly never tasted Primitivo like them and I had the sense that these were something of a one-off.’

He also felt that they had aged beautifully: ‘Looking at vintages like 2000 and 2007, for example, amazingly well. These vintages had great balance and were just meltingly delicious and complex. A fresh, almost zesty acidity was a common to most of them – even the oldest wines‚Ķ¬†I want to drink more of these wines. They are so distinctive – that amazing combo of stewed strawberries, cherry, clove, cocoa, bitter almond, hints of negroni. These are¬†really remarkable wines – all the more so after a few years of bottle age.’

Many of the wines managed to retain a fine balance, showing warmth without sweetness, bitterness without astringency, fruit without jamminess and toastiness without oak. This is surely down to the organic approach and the intense focus on detail and precision.

Thanks to Pasquale for bringing these rare specimens of Primitivo to London and for celebrating Fatalone’s 30th anniversary with us. And to Enoteca Turi for hosting the tasting and the wine dinner afterwards.


Interested in finding out more about the wine of Fatalone? Buy online here or contact us directly…

Retail: shop@lescaves.co.uk / 01483 554750

Leave a Reply